More WP7 Drama with microSD Cards
The microSD card debacle concerning Windows Phone 7 devices keeps getting weirder and weirder. I’ve previously reported that most WP7 devices have hidden, internal microSD card slots that actually function as their internal storage. The cards are removable and swappable for a higher capacity one, but WP7 rewrites them so that they can only be used with the device.
According to Microsoft in an email to eWeek, “Windows Phone 7 does not support swapping microSD cards in and out…cards inserted into a Windows Phone 7 device are integrated into the device’s file system and are intended to be a permanent modification to the device.” Right. So what does that exactly mean? Microsoft further clarified and said that once you put your own microSD card into a WP7 smartphone, the card is rewritten and locked down. Why though? “This behavior is by design and is intended to ensure a consistently high-quality and secure end-user experience.” Hmm, sounds like some standard Microsoft rhetoric to me.
Microsoft is apparently working on certifying specific microSD cards as ‘Certified for Windows Phone 7’ and will then sell them itself, through carriers and other outlets. I’m not quite sure what is going to make these certified WP7 microSD cards any different than what you can get at your local Wal-Mart, but do expect them to cost more than one at your local Wal-Mart.
(To be honest, Microsoft and Co. probably just want to make sure that the cards you buy for your WP7 device has a high random access speed, something particularly important in actual hard drive specs but not taken into account by microSD card ratings which measure overall transfer speeds).
With so many WP7 devices having these hidden microSD card slots and future WP7 devices expected to have ones actually designed to be removed, is anyone a little worried about what is going on here? microSD is supposed to mean swappable storage on the go for cheap. If Microsoft can pull off this nonsense with WP7, expect more of our favorite standards to get butchered in the future. Yes, you bought a Bluetooth headset for your iPhone 5 and the iPhone 5 supports Bluetooth, but you need an Apple Bluetooth headset to work. If someone told me that, I’d have to slowly count to ten and then leave before my nerd-rage could manifest itself.
C’mon guys, we just want stuff that is widely compatible and plays nice. Reformatting our microSD cards so that they are WP7 only isn’t friendly and it isn’t good business.
Let me know what you think about this in the comments.
Tags: WP7, microSD, swappable
Isn’t this a problem with a lot of phones already? Ie, I’m pretty sure that my uSD card is used for install space on my Nokia. Sure I can remove it, but if I do I lose important data.
On the iPhone today, there IS no uSD. You want an upgrade, buy a new phone. Also the price hike is enormous. It is better than that.
PS, if you want a headset to work properly (full Music control, etc) with an iPhone, you DO have to buy a special iPhone one. Except iPhone want such a premium for their special Encryption Chip, no-one has bothered yet.
I dont see this as a huge problem.
I like on the N8 you can plug in external USB drives.
[Reply]
If the microsd cards are designed to be a semi-permanent storage upgrade. If I’m a businessman and don’t need media storage, I can forgo the memory upgrade and get the 8GB onboard storage at the cheapest rate. If I’m a multimedia junky, I can upgrade with a 32GB microsd and have 40GB total! It’s gonna cost me more however. What is so bad about having this option? It was never intended to be swapped in and out… otherwise they would have put it on the external part of the phone, not inside the back cover under the battery. The fact that the cards weren’t ready at launch is AT&T and Samsung’s fault for rushing it out without the proper microsd support.
[Reply]
Apple had the Antennagate and Microsoft now the Cardgate.
[Reply]
Per an associate in the Scottsdale, AZ Microsoft Store – unless the phone is “designed” to have its card swapped – you can’t, even if it’s a certified card. In short, unless you get the Focus, you’re kind of SOL.
[Reply]
rodneyj Reply:
November 16th, 2010 at 5:05 pm
greed greed greed
[Reply]
Sean MacLeod Reply:
November 16th, 2010 at 5:05 pm
@rodneyj, Thats how I see it as well!
[Reply]