RIM Bows Under Pressure and Agrees to Work with India
Research In Motion (RIM) has agreed to work with India and presumably allow the country to access encrypted, personal BlackBerry information on its servers in Canada. The decision came after India threatened to shut down RIM’s operations in the country because its intelligence community was unable to intercept information and messages sent between BlackBerrys. India deemed it a security concern and it looks like RIM has capitulated.
The future of BlackBerrys in the United Arab Emirates (UAE) is still in doubt, and RIM has joined the ranks of Western companies expanding aboard and experiencing hostility from foreign governments. Google is currently locked in a battle with China regarding the future of its operations there and Skype has also come under attack in India. It looks like unless you live in North America or Western Europe, you are not going to be allowed to use commercially available encryption to ensure the privacy of your data.
While the news that RIM has decided to take the easy and more profitable way out of giving India the key to the country’s BlackBerry data, the news certainly lets us feel more comfortable about how secure our BlackBerrys are. While India’s intelligence community certainly is not the NSA by any stretch of the imagination, when it comes to decrypting and intercepting information, at least the threat of our device being stolen, hacked and our personal information stolen just got even smaller.
So, BlackBerry users. Did RIM do the right thing in this situation? Or is it taking care of its balance sheet before it takes care of its customers? What are Western companies supposed to do in situations like this? Let us know what you think of this whole mess.
Tags: RIM, India banning BlackBerrys, encryption
While India’s intelligence community is nothing like the NSA, the Indian intelligence agencies had already cracked the Blackberry Enterprise encryption in 2008 when they were testing real time non-enterprise user encryption on different cell networks in India with the help of the National Technical Research Organization- one of the many intelligence agencies responsible for SIGINT. The main problem they had was with access to real time Blackberry Enterprise encryption.
The NSA and the US government have long ago mandated the ability to monitor, record and trace any and all communications inside the US on all communications networks. The lack of awareness of this fact is what is leading to the surprised reactions by Westerners about RIM acquiescing to Indian Intelligence agencies demands.
Already, India monitors in some form or the other all cellphones, landlines, emails, VOIP sat phones etc. The fact that they are interested in monitoring yet another device is hardly surprising to Indians considering the threat scenario Indian cities face.
[Reply]